Frozen Enrichment: The Chill Truth About Freezer Food Toys for Dogs

Is the world making you feel like you HAVE to stuff food into toys, freeze them, and serve them to your dog like some Michelin-starred chef? Like your dog’s life is incomplete without gourmet freezer delights? Yeah, I’m calling BS on that.

Here’s what set me off: someone on an enrichment Facebook group got called out because she dared to say she didn’t want to freeze food for her dog in the freezer she uses for the humans. The commenter’s reasoning? "Dogs need it." No explanation. Just dogs need it. And let me tell you, I was not impressed (nicely said).

Let’s get real: enrichment is not a one-size-fits-all deal. It’s supposed to be tailored to your dog’s preferences and your lifestyle. What works for one dog might be a flop for another—and that’s fine. But let’s break this freezer-food obsession down, shall we?

Why People Love Frozen Food Enrichment Toys

Here are the "why frozen is fabulous" arguments you’ll see all over the internet:

1. It lasts longer

2. Keeps your dog busy

3. You can prep in batches

4. Easy enrichment hack

5. Low-calorie option

6. Keeps your dog cool

7. Fun way to enrich your dog’s life

8. Provides mental stimulation

9. Licking is calming

10. Great summer activity to replace a walk

11. Keeps your dog hydrated

Sounds perfect, right? Well, hold your Kong-shaped horses because every single one of these points has some serious nuance. Let’s dig in.

The Real Deal: Why Frozen Food Enrichment Toys Might Not Work for Your Dog

1. It lasts longer

   Sure, but that’s only if your dog enjoys the challenge and has the patience. For some dogs it easily turns into a frustration fest or they’ll walk away and wait for it to thaw. Is that enriching? No. It’s just annoying.

   
   

2. Keeps your dog busy

   Busy doing what, exactly? Frantically licking? Pacing in frustration? Some dogs don’t enjoy these kind of activities. If your dog looks stressed or gives up, it’s not keeping them busy—it’s wasting their time.

   
   

3. You can prep in batches

   For you, maybe. Your dog doesn’t care that you just created 15 Instagram-worthy enrichment toys. What matters is whether they’ll actually enjoy it—and some dogs just won’t.

   
   

4. Easy enrichment hack

   Easy for you, but is it actually enriching for your dog? Just because it’s frozen doesn’t magically make it "better." Observe your dog. Are they loving it, or just tolerating it?

   
   

5. Low-calorie option

   Depends on what you’re putting in there, doesn’t it? Peanut butter, yogurt, and treats can add up fast. That "low-calorie" claim? Might be more of a calorie bomb than you think.

   
   

6. Keeps your dog cool

   Does it, though? Sure, the frozen food cools their tongue, but licking activates a lot of head and neck muscles. That activity generates heat, and they can’t pant while they’re busy licking. Is this really helping your dog stay cool? Questionable, we need more research on that!

   
   

7. Fun way to enrich your dog’s life

   Only if your dog finds it fun. Some dogs love it. Others get frustrated, bored, or even sore from all that licking (more on that in a sec).

   
   

8. Provides mental stimulation

   Licking isn’t really "mental stimulation." Sure, some of the toys are more complex and need some figuring out, but most of them are simple repetitive licking. Mental stimulation involves problem-solving, exploring, or learning—not turning their tongue into a popsicle machine.

   
   

9. Licking is calming

   True, licking can be calming. But if your dog can’t access the frozen food or gets frantic, that calming effect goes right out the window. Frustration is not enrichment.

   
   

10. Great summer activity to replace a walk

    Nope. Licking a frozen toy doesn’t replace the physical and mental benefits of a walk. Sure, skip the walk on a super-hot day, but don’t fool yourself into thinking frozen licking is the same thing. This blog tells you all about the importance of both mental and physical exercise.

    
    

11. Keeps your dog hydrated

    Hydrated, yes… if you’re freezing water-based foods. There are easier ways to keep them hydrated, like, you know, water.

The Bottom Line

Frozen food toys are not a need. They’re a nice-to-have. If your dog enjoys them, great! If they don’t, no big deal. There are so many other ways to enrich your dog’s life.

The most important thing is that enrichment is actually enriching for YOUR dog. Not Instagram-perfect. Just something your dog loves and benefits from. So, if freezer enrichment isn’t your thing or your dog’s thing? Skip it. You’re not failing your dog. You’re being smart and attentive—and that’s what really matters.

Now, go give your dog a belly rub and stop stressing over freezer drama. You’ve got this.

Puzzle Dog is an expert in guiding people and their dogs in their 'puzzle journey'. We use the Dutch Hersenwerk method in our work. Hersenwerk is a harmonious interplay between humans and animals, based on sensory experience, customization and freedom of choice. 

In our guidance we focus on the individual dog and their human; customizing the puzzle activity will make it enriching for both of you! You can find our courses in the Puzzle Dog Academy.

We have FREE tips to get you started!